inspired. innovative. individual.

News

Claim against GECA, Environmental Assurance and Petar Johnson

Progress Report 5. Dated 04.05.10

INSTYLE v GOOD ENVIRONMENTAL CHOICE (GECA), ENVIRONMENTAL ASSURANCE AND PETAR JOHNSON

We have received many requests for updates as to what is happening in our proceedings against GECA, Environmental Assurance, and Petar Johnson.

Unfortunately, the determination of these proceedings will take much longer than we anticipated.

Instyle applied to the Federal Court for an order to restrain each of GECA, Environmental Assurance and Petar Johnson from making unfounded claims in the market place about Instyle and its products similar to those made in the market advisories which were widely distributed in late September 2009.

As a result of this application, GECA, Environmental Assurance and Petar Johnson have each given undertakings to the Court that they will not publish similar statements about Instyle in the marketplace without first giving Instyle the opportunity to object and if necessary to take action to prevent them or any one of them from doing so.

If you become aware of GECA, Environmental Assurance or Petar Johnson making any statements about Instyle or its products, then we ask you to inform us immediately.

In the meantime, Instyle will continue to pursue its application to the Federal Court to a conclusion as quickly as possible.


Living Ethics magazine is published by the St James Ethics Centre.

INSTYLE was used as their Case Study model (to encourage sustainability in other small businesses) for their 20 year Anniversary Edition.


This article, "Sustainability with style" was published in Living Ethics: Issue 79 Autumn 2010.

Established by Michael Fitzsimons in 1987, Instyle Contract Textiles was created with a vision to build an internationally respected textile company. Michael has been a strong supporter of the Centre’s National Small to Medium Enterprise Project. In particular, he has donated his time to participate in focus groups for the Good Business Register and has joined the Centre on panels at conferences. Holistic, practical and no-nonsense are words that describe Instyle’s approach to sustainability, writes Tracy Mak.

Textile company Instyle’s sustainability journey began in 2002 at a company conference. Our clients – architects and interior designers – began asking for green furnishing fabrics and our sales team sought to meet this demand. Our Managing Director, Michael Fitzsimons, doesn’t do anything halfheartedly and decided to adopt a ‘whole of company’ approach to sustainability.This decision required significant investment and commitment: a new position had to be created as the company did not have the resources or knowledge required.

Like many companies, we started by picking the low hanging fruit. There were no sophisticated technologies, just simple, practical and easy-to-implement initiatives. By using less and recycling, the cost savings were instant. For example, reducing the thickness of our transport packaging achieved cost savings of 20% and sending waste to landfill is two to three times more expensive than recycling.

Initially there was some resistance to changing “the way things are done around here”. When we looked at reducing the weight of packaging plastic to reduce the overall impact of our transport packaging, warehouse staff feared this would provide less protection and the fabric could get damaged in transport.

This kind of concern was overcome by open communication. For instance in this case, we surveyed our fabric manufacturers about their packaging to find out how we could provide the same level of protection as before but by using plastic that was thinner than our own. We shared this information with the warehouse staff who were then satisified because their priorities could also be met.

After discussions with the team – proposing ideas, gaining feedback and addressing any concerns – we could then work towards a solution that met all of our objectives: delivering fabrics safely and reducing our impact at the same time. Plus, we have always had strong leadership. This has resulted in sustainability becoming integrated into the culture of Instyle, where it is everyone’s responsibility to achieve environmental goals.

One of our goals was to develop a benchmark sustainable textile collection. It took us two years to research and develop the LIFE Sustainable Textiles® collection. It became the first sustainable textile in Australia to have minimal impact over the whole lifecycle. The fabrics are made locally from locally grown eco-wool (low pesticide wool) and they are recyclable.

This was totally different to what our competitors were doing – importing fabrics made from plastic bottle waste which still contained hazardous substances and could not be recycled here in Australia. As a result, LIFE Textiles® has become Instyle’s most successful product range.

In 2008 we were presented with an opportunity to further improve LIFE Textiles® when we met with Dr Jim Watts, a former CSIRO scientist who had developed a unique selective breeding system (SRS®) for merino sheep. SRS merino sheep are ‘wrinkle-free’, therefore they are naturally resistant to flystrike and don’t require mulesing*. Soon after that meeting, we visited some SRS farms in Wellington NSW, where through holistic farm management and sheep farming with minimal or zero pesticides, fertilisers and herbicides were regenerating and improving the land.

After seeing the difference between adjacent degraded, conventional farmlands, and thriving, holistic farmlands we decided to source wool from non-mulesed sheep raised on holistically-managed farms. We have termed this EthEco® wool, because it combines both ethical and environmental considerations.

Consequently, Instyle has won numerous environmental awards such as the United Nations’ World Environment Day Awards and the NSW Government Green Globe Awards. These have lifted our company profile.

Instyle has become regarded as a leader in sustainability but only because our efforts are genuine. We are committed to real environmental change that goes beyond our organisation. For several years, we have challenged current industry practices and standards such as the Green Building Council and the Good Environmental Choice Australia (GECA) which reward ‘business as usual’ practices.

As a small-to-medium business with a lone voice, it’s been an uphill battle but this has resulted in small signs of improvement within the textiles and building and interiors industries. Going the extra mile requires great commitment. Sustainability has given the company a sense of collective purpose and has made us more passionate in what we do. We have also enjoyed closer relationships with our supply chain and increased customer loyalty. Sustainability is good business practice for the future.

References/footnotes:
* Mulesing is the practice of removing skin from a sheep’s hindquarters. Most merino sheep in Australia are mulesed and without it, these sheep are highly susceptible to flystrike.


Claim against GECA, Environmental Assurance and Petar Johnson

Progress Report 4. Dated 06.10.2009

GECA, ENVIRONMENTAL ASSURANCE AND PETAR JOHNSON’S LEGAL REPRESENTATIVES ACCEPT THAT INSTYLE’S CLAIMS ARE LEGITIMATE

GECA and Environmental Assurance have made public statements suggesting that Instyle’s claims in its Federal Court case are “misconceived”, and that Instyle’s action in bringing its claims is unlawful.

On the last occasion this matter was before the Court on 9 September, 2009, GECA’s, Environmental Assurance’s and Petar Johnson’s barrister made the following statement –

"There is no challenge being made to the fact that ... the applicant’s (INSTYLE’s) case meets the threshold of reasonable prospects of success".

Instyle will seek to have the case heard by the Court as a matter of urgency.


 

Claim against GECA, Environmental Assurance and Petar Johnson

Progress Report 3. Dated 22.09.2009

GECA filed its defence on 15 September, 2009, and GECS and Petar Johnson filed a joint defence on 15th September, 2009.

A further directions hearing was held in this matter on 16 September 2009.

At the directions hearing, the Court ordered each party to compile and provide to the other party a list of categories of documents.

The other party will thereafter be required to make available for inspection any documents which it has and which fall within any of the listed categories. This is part of a process known as 'discovery'.

Instyle has also become aware that GECA disposed of its interest in Environmental Assurance (GECS)
on 30 June 2009, and that on the 10 September 2009 Petar Johnson resigned as a director of GECA.



Claim against GECA, Environmental Assurance and Petar Johnson

Progress Report 2. Dated 28.08.2009

Instyle filed its claim against GECA, Environmental Assurance and Petar Johnson in the Federal Court of Australia on 25 June 2009 alleging breaches by them of the Trade Practices Act and of the NSW Fair Trading Act. 

Pursuant to the Federal Court Rules, GECA, Environmental Assurance and Petar Johnson were required to file their defences by 5 August 2009.

As at 28 August 2009, GECA, Environmental Assurance and Petar Johnson have still not filed their defences to Instyle's claims. 

At directions hearings in the Court, GECA, Environmental Assurance and Petar Johnson have applied for and been granted extensions of time within which to file their defences.

At the directions hearing on 27 August, 2009, GECA, Environmental Assurance and Petar Johnson applied to the Court to be allowed up until 15 September, 2009 within which to file their defences, and this application was granted.  Before the respondents sought this extension, the defence was to have been filed on or before 1 September, 2009.

Once GECA, Petar Johnson and Environmental Assurance have filed their defences, the issues which will have to be determined at a hearing will then be known, and the Court will make further directions about what each party then has to do to progress the matter towards the hearing. 

Instyle is hoping that its claims will progress quickly towards a hearing once the defences have been filed.


 

Claim against GECA, Environmental Assurance and Petar Johnson

Progress Report 1. Dated 25.08.2009

As you know, Instyle filed its claim against GECA, Environmental Assurance and Petar Johnson in the Federal Court of Australia on 25 June 2009 alleging breaches by them of the Trade Practices Act and of the NSW Fair Trading Act. 

As at 25 August, 2009, GECA, Environmental Assurance and Petar Johnson had still not yet filed their defences to Instyle's claims.  At a directions hearing in the Federal Court on 20 August, 2009, GECA, Environmental Assurance and Petar Johnson were directed to file their defences by close of business on 1 September 2009.

Once GECA, Petar Johnson and Environmental Assurance have filed their defences, the issues which will have to be determined at a hearing will then be known, and the Court will make further directions about what each party then has to do to progress the matter towards the hearing.


 

 

IMPORTANT NOTICE

Dated 03.07.09

Instyle Contract Textiles Pty Ltd (Instyle) has commenced proceedings in the Federal Court of Australia against:

  • Good Environmental Choice–Australia Ltd (GECA) (Australia’s national environmental labeling program administrator),

  • Good Environmental Choice Services Pty Ltd (GECS) t/as Environmental Assurance, and

  • Petar Johnson.

Basis of Instyle’s Claims

GECA has published “Standard No 28‑2006: Furniture and Fittings” which sets out environmental performance criteria for furniture.

The GECA furniture standard clearly states that the fabric used to upholster GECA certified furniture:

  • does not need to be certified with GECA’s Standard No 19: Textiles, and

  • nor does the fabric need to meet the requirements of that standard unless the fabric contributes 10% or more to the weight of the furniture, which will rarely be the case.

Instyle is alleging the Trade Practices Act 1979 and the NSW Fair Trading Act 1987 have been breached:

  • GECA and Environmental Assurance have issued environmental product declarations which contain false statements. The alleged false statements are to the effect that the fabric used must be certified to the GECA textile standard for upholstered furniture to be fully compliant with the GECA furniture standard, and consequently to earn the maximum Green Star credit points available.

  • Environmental Assurance and Petar Johnson have falsely represented to one of Instyle’s customers, a major furniture supplier, that in order to achieve certification of its furniture with the GECA furniture standard, that supplier could only use Instyle’s fabrics if those fabrics had been assessed and verified as being compliant with the GECA textile standard. Instyle alleges that Environmental Assurance and Petar Johnson suggested to that supplier that it use a GECA certified textile.

Further, Instyle is alleging that:

Each of GECA and Environmental Assurance control the certification of furniture on a whole of product basis, and

Each of GECA, Environmental Assurance and Petar Johnson gain financially from increasing the demand for certification services and the sales of GECA certified product,

and that in those circumstances, the making of the alleged false representations by Environmental Assurance and Petar Johnson was unconscionable and constituted a breach by them of the NSW Fair Trading Act 1987.

As a consequence of the alleged conduct of each of GECA, Environmental Assurance and Petar Johnson, Instyle alleges that it has suffered substantial losses.

Instyle is seeking orders restraining the alleged unlawful conduct, corrective action and public notification, and damages.

Background

The Green Building Council of Australia administers the ‘Green Star’ rating system, which is an environmental performance rating system for buildings.

Governments at all levels and major corporations are increasingly demanding that new and upgraded buildings establish their environmental credentials and achieve a Green Star rating, which is in turn increasing the demand for products which will earn credit points towards that Green Star rating.

Office furniture is one of the products which can earn credit points. To earn credit points, the furniture must satisfy one or more of the applicable Green Building Council environmental performance criteria, or alternatively the furniture can be certified on a whole of product basis from a third party recognised by the Green Building Council. The Green Building Council encourages whole of product certification as it is simpler for Green Star assessors and buyers to ascertain their entitlement to Green Star credit points for that furniture. The GBCA’s rating tools automatically award the maximum credit points to furniture which has been certified on a whole of product basis.

The only third party recognised by the Green Building Council which can provide this certification for upholstered office furniture is Good Environmental Choice Australia (GECA).

GECA publishes standards which set out specific environmental criteria for products to meet. Suppliers of products which comply with an applicable GECA standard are licensed to market those products under the “Good Environmental Choice’ label and more significantly, can market the fact that those products earn the maximum available credit points towards a Green Star rating.

Environmental Assurance is contracted by GECA to assess products and verify their compliance with the applicable GECA standard, and to issue environmental product declarations (EPDs) for those products. Each EPD contains a certification of compliance and information about the environmental performance of the certified products.

Petar Johnson is a director of GECA, and is the sole director and the holder of a major shareholder interest in Environmental Assurance.

Environmental Assurance and Petar Johnson (via his major shareholder interest) respectively receive fees and dividends from the supply of the certification services, and GECA also receives a royalty from the sales of products which have been certified as compliant with an applicable GECA standard. ASIC records show that GECA holds more than 16% of the shares in Environmental Assurance as trustee for an undisclosed beneficiary.

Instyle’s Environmental Credentials

Instyle is an environmentally responsible company and is the winner of a number of major environmental awards:

2009 FINALIST United Nations’ World Environment Day Award – Best Specific Environmental Initiative
2008 WINNER United Nations’ World Environment Day Award - Business Sustainability Award  
2008 WINNER Sustainability Green Globe Awards – Premier’s Sustainability Excellence Award
2008 WINNER Sustainability Green Globe Awards - Industry Environmental Sustainability
2008 WINNER Sustainability Green Globe Awards - Small Business Environmental Sustainability
2007 FINALIST Banksia Environmental Award - Sustainability
2006 FINALIST Banksia Environmental Award - Sustainability

Instyle is also environmentally pro‑active at an industry level. Instyle is particularly concerned about the following matters:

  • That the Green Building Council has prescribed environmental performance criteria for products in the Green Star ‘Materials’ assessment category which do not accord with criteria prescribed by its international counterparts, and which limit the incentive for suppliers to be environmentally innovative.

  • That the Green Building Council has given a monopoly over standard setting and the certification of many products to GECA.

  • That the Green Building Council does not supervise the content of the GECA standards. Instyle considers that GECA’s textile standard is a ‘business as usual standard’ as it can certify non environmental products such as 100% polyester, acrylic, nylon, polypropylene and PVC vinyl. Furthermore Instyle alleges the GECA Textile Standard is not lifecycle based as it addresses only chemical inputs and wastewater and does not address other lifecycle issues such as resource use, energy, water or recyclability (with the exception of PVC).

  • That the Green Building Council has countenanced the close relationship between GECA and Environmental Assurance which is evident from their common directorship and sharing of income. The lack of independence between the standard setting body and the certifying body is inconsistent with the requirements of the international environmental performance standards which GECA and Environmental Assurance state they comply with on numerous occasions on their websites and in their other promotional materials.

  • That GECA charges a royalty to suppliers for the sales of certified products, and that the Green Building Council has not taken any action to stop GECA from charging this royalty.

Instyle continues to actively lobby the Green Building Council about these matters and has called upon it to immediately suspend the use of the GECA Furniture and Fittings and Textiles standards in its Green Stars Rating Tools.

For more information, please contact:

Michael Fitzsimons, Managing Director 02 9317 0250

Tracy Mak, Environmental Manager 02 9317 0283


 

INSTYLE. United Nations’ World Environment Day Awards’ Finalist 2009

  INSTYLE CONTRACT TEXTILES is proud to be selected again as a finalist for the United Nations’ World Environment Day Awards 2009 - this time for Best Specific Environmental Initiative for its new EthEco® wool sourcing program.

For the past 18 months INSTYLE has been working with its supply chain and in particular wool growers to further improve its wool sourcing specification from eco wool (low pesticide wool) to EthEco® wool.

INSTYLE is the first company in the furnishings industry to integrate both ethical and environmental considerations in its wool sourcing. The company signed the industry’s first ethical wool supply agreement with SRS® wool growers in 2008. SRS® Merino sheep do not require mulesing.


EthEco® wool is sourced from non-mulesed sheep that are well cared for on holistically-managed farms - improving animal welfare, human health and care for the environment.

Customers can visit online a typical farm where EthEco® wool is grown and see how these farms are managed with minimal environmental impact through INSTYLE’s traceability program FARM TO FABRIC™ - available here:

Click here to use your Farm To Fabric™ interactive program.

The release of EthEco® wool coincides with the United Nations’ International Year of Natural Fibres and is sourced exclusively for INSTYLE’s benchmark LIFE Sustainable Textiles® collection.

The World Environment Day Awards acknowledge local actions to address global environmental issues. This year’s theme, ‘Your Planet Needs You - UNite to Combat Climate Change’ reflects the vital need for nations to work together in combating climate change.

Michael Fitzsimons, Managing Director of INSTYLE says, “Holistically-managed farms that focus on 100% groundcover of perennial grasses can help in combating climate change as the perennials absorb carbon dioxide from the atmosphere and emit oxygen”.

This is all further proof of INSTYLE’s strong commitment in producing sustainable and ethical textiles.

Winners of the 2009 UN Awards will be announced on World Environment Day (5 June) in Melbourne.




New to the Fold' Country Style Magazine May 2009.

Feature on non-mulesed Sheep and Holistic Farming.


Click here to read more...



Farm To Fabric

INSTYLE's new traceability program - FARM TO FABRIC™ - allows you to select a fabric and see how it is made beginning with the farm that produced the EthEco® wool fibre.

You can see the environment the sheep were farmed in, meet the farmers and their families and learn about how they manage the land with minimal environmental impact.

Click here to read more...

To trace your LIFE Textiles® click here


Bruce, Hugh and Geoff Taylor - EthEcoŽ wool growers



INSTYLE signs first ethical + environmental wool supply agreement

Fabric made using wool from a breed of Merino sheep that don’t require mulesing will soon be available, through Australia’s first-ever ethical wool supply agreement for the furnishings industry.

Former CSIRO scientist, Dr Jim Watts, developed the Merino breed to have softer, more flexible skin that has less wrinkles and folds, known as SRS® sheep for their Soft-Rolling- Skin. The absence of skin corrugations ensures the animals are not at risk of developing flystrike and therefore do not need to be mulesed like the traditional, more-wrinkled Merino breeds.

mulesing

Chad Taylor, SRS® Wool Producer, Michael Fitzsimons Managing Director  of INSTYLE CONTRACT TEXTILES and exclusive producer of EthEco® furnishing fabrics,  and SRS® Sheep Breeding Consultant Dr Jim Watts showing superior quality and staple length of EthEco® wool.

Click here to read more ...


 

BACKGROUND TO AWARDS

Instyle Contract Textiles Pty Ltd is a specialist in the design, marketing and distribution of commercial interior furnishing textiles (for offices, healthcare, hospitality, transport, education, public buildings, etc).

'Click here to read more about the background to the awards...'


 

Green Globes Logo

 

 

A FEW MORE OF LIFE'S ACHIEVEMENTS

INSTYLE CONTRACT TEXTILES is proud to have won three
Awards in the 2008 Sustainability Green Globe Awards.

• The Premier's Sustainability Excellence Award,
• Industry - Environmental Sustainability award,
• Small Business Environmental Sustainability award.

 

 

 

Green Globes Award
Michael Fitzsimons Managing Director of Instyle receiving an award from the Hon. Verity Firth Minister for Climate Change and the Environment.


INSTYLE WINS 3 SUSTAINABILITY GREEN GLOBE AWARDS

green globe awards

Click the image or here to download the pdf.


2007 Sustainability Category - Banksia Awards

Awarded for outstanding achievements in minimising the environmental footprint of a company.

'Click here to read more about the Banksia Awards...'


INSTYLE are finalists in the 2006 Banksia Awards : Sustainability Category

Click here to read more about the Banksia Awards...


INSTYLE providing LIFE Support for Medecins Sans Frontieres

Click here to read more ...


Invitation to work on the US Sustainable Textile Standard. INSTYLE.

Click here to read more ...


Our cars are invisible - INSTYLE has signed up with Greenfleet

Click here to read more ...